Berkonomics

How much equity should early angel investors take?

If you are raising your first outside money from other than your earliest friends and family round, plan on selling 20 to 25 percent of the company. That is what angel groups have informally expected in their first round for as long as I have been writing checks.

The percentage is not what you negotiate. It is what falls out of two numbers you do negotiate: how much you raise, and what the company is worth before the money goes in. Founders who argue about the percentage instead of the valuation lose twice, once at this round and again at the next one if too aggressive now.

Why “what percentage should I give up” is the wrong question

Ownership sold is round size divided by post money valuation. That is the whole formula. Raise $1 million on a $3 million pre money and you have sold 25 percent. Raise the same $1 million on a $4 million pre money and you have sold 20 percent.

The Angel Capital Association’s own guidance for angel groups makes this order of operations explicit: structuring and negotiating the deal begins with the valuation of the company. Their illustration is blunt. All other factors equal, $500,000 invested at a $1.5 million pre money is a more attractive percentage ownership for the investor than the same $500,000 at a $3.5 million pre money. Nothing about the company changed. Only the price did.

So when a founder tells me they will not go above 20 percent, I ask what they are raising and what they think the business is worth. Those two answers set the percentage.

The trap for both angels and founders

Early-stage valuations have outpaced company ability to perform (grow into the valuations) during these past years.  This has happened even as cost to create product and market the result have dramatically decreased.  In the first angel group round, average pre-money valuations have increased to a point where ultimate angel returns will decline, discouraging future angels from stepping up.  It is to the advantage of all that valuations and SAFE caps remain low enough to be attractive to the investors.    

An angel group that ends up with a tiny slice, because the valuation or the SAFE cap was pushed too high, has little influence on the board of that portfolio company. You have taken money from experienced operators and priced them out of the one thing they were going to be most useful for.

That is an observation about how boards work. Influence follows ownership. If your angels hold 8 percent spread across twenty people, no one at that table has the standing or the economic motivation to fight for you in the hard conversation two years from now.   

This is the conversation I have been having with founders and boards for decades, and it is what the weekly Berkonomics newsletter is built on: one practical lesson at a time, from the chair where these deals actually get priced.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Skip to content